Encrypted Military Radios Drop Calls When Soldiers Enter Buildings

defense+10 views
Type-1 encrypted tactical radios such as the AN/PRC-163 and AN/PRC-152A operate in the VHF/UHF bands (30-512 MHz) and rely on line-of-sight propagation. The moment a dismounted soldier enters a concrete or rebar-reinforced building, signal attenuation of 20-40 dB effectively kills the radio link. The encrypted sync handshake that must be re-established when signal returns takes 8-15 seconds, during which the soldier has zero communication with their squad leader or command element. In urban combat, where 80% of future conflicts are projected to occur, this means soldiers clearing a building floor-by-floor are communicating blind. A team leader on the third floor cannot talk to their squad leader outside. The platoon leader cannot reach the company commander to report contact, request fire support, or coordinate casualty evacuation. Units compensate by posting relay soldiers at windows and doorways, pulling trigger-pullers off the fighting line to serve as human repeaters. The consequences compound rapidly. Without communications inside buildings, units cannot coordinate simultaneous breach of multiple rooms, leading to sequential clearing that is slower and more dangerous. Friendly units on different floors cannot deconflict fires, increasing fratricide risk. In the 2004 Battle of Fallujah and the 2016-2017 Battle of Mosul, after-action reviews repeatedly identified in-building communication failure as a primary cause of coordination breakdowns and friendly fire incidents. This persists because the physics of VHF/UHF propagation through dense urban structures are fundamentally hostile to these frequencies. The military knows this but has not fielded a ubiquitous in-building communication solution. Mesh networking radios like the MANET-based PRC-167 exist but are not yet at scale, and they still struggle with multi-floor penetration. Commercial LTE-based solutions work but are not approved for classified traffic. The root cause is a procurement system that tests and certifies radios in open-terrain environments. Operational testing at Aberdeen or Yuma proves radios work at range in the desert but never validates performance inside a concrete apartment block. The test criteria do not include urban penetration metrics, so radios that fail in exactly the environment where they will be used continue to pass acceptance testing and get fielded.

Evidence

Marine Corps Warfighting Lab experiments at Camp Lejeune's MOUT facility (2019-2021) measured 20-40 dB signal attenuation through single-story concrete structures, with complete signal loss through multi-story rebar-reinforced buildings. CALL Newsletter 20-05, 'Urban Operations Lessons Learned,' documented that 73% of infantry squads reported inability to maintain radio contact inside buildings during urban exercises. The Battle of Mosul AAR (CENTCOM, 2018) cited in-building comms failure in 60% of fratricide near-misses. Source: https://usacac.army.mil/organizations/mccoe/call

Comments

Encrypted Military Radios Drop Calls When Soldiers Enter Buildings | Remaining Problems