People on probation pay $25-$100/month in supervision fees just to not be in jail, and 32 states jail them if they can't pay

legal0 views
In 38 states, people on probation or parole must pay a monthly supervision fee ranging from $25 to over $100 just for the privilege of being supervised instead of incarcerated. In Louisiana, fees run $71-$121/month. In Georgia, private probation companies charge $30-$60/month plus enrollment fees, drug test fees, and rescheduling fees. These are not optional — 32 states authorize probation revocation or extension if fees go unpaid. This matters because two-thirds of people on probation earn less than $20,000 per year, and 38% earn under $10,000. When you make $800/month and owe $100 in supervision fees plus $50 for mandatory drug tests plus $300 for court-ordered classes, you are choosing between paying your probation officer and buying groceries. Miss a payment and your probation gets extended — which means more months of fees. It is a debt spiral with a jail cell at the bottom. The Supreme Court ruled in Bearden v. Georgia (1983) that you cannot jail someone solely for inability to pay, but in practice, officers file technical violations for nonpayment and judges revoke probation without conducting the required ability-to-pay hearing. This problem persists because supervision fees exist to shift the cost of the justice system onto the people it punishes. States face budget pressure and see fee revenue as a way to fund probation departments without raising taxes. Private probation companies have an even starker incentive — their entire business model depends on collecting fees from the people they supervise. The population being exploited has no political power: they cannot vote in many states, they cannot afford lobbyists, and they are socially stigmatized. The result is a system where being poor is effectively a probation violation.

Evidence

Fines and Fees Justice Center 50-State Survey: https://finesandfeesjusticecenter.org/articles/50-state-survey-probation-and-parole-fees/ | Prison Policy Initiative income data: https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2019/04/09/probation_income/ | Human Rights Watch 'Set Up to Fail' report on private probation: https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/02/20/set-fail/impact-offender-funded-private-probation-poor | Bearden v. Georgia, 461 U.S. 660 (1983)

Comments