Data brokers sell U.S. military personnel geolocation, health conditions, and financial data for $0.12 per record, and law enforcement agencies purchase location data without warrants to bypass the Fourth Amendment
technologytechnology0 views
Data brokers in the United States sell comprehensive personal data on active-duty military members and veterans -- including home addresses, real-time geolocation, net worth, health conditions, religion, and information about their children -- for as little as $0.12 per record, with no verification of buyer identity or intent. Simultaneously, federal agencies including the FBI, IRS, DEA, Department of Defense, and Department of Homeland Security purchase geolocation data from commercial brokers to track Americans' movements without obtaining warrants, court orders, or subpoenas. Why it matters: foreign adversaries can cheaply acquire data to profile, blackmail, and target military personnel and their families, so national security is compromised at scale for the price of a bulk data purchase, so law enforcement agencies use commercial data purchases as a constitutional workaround to conduct warrantless surveillance, so the Fourth Amendment's protection against unreasonable search is functionally nullified by the third-party doctrine loophole, so Americans have no practical way to prevent government tracking of their movements because the data exists in commercial databases they cannot access or delete. The structural root cause is that the third-party doctrine -- the legal principle that data voluntarily shared with a company loses Fourth Amendment protection -- creates a constitutional loophole where the government can purchase surveillance capabilities that would otherwise require a warrant, and Congress has failed to pass legislation closing this loophole despite bipartisan recognition of the problem.
Evidence
Duke University Tech Policy Lab study (November 2023) found military personnel data sold for $0.12 per record with no buyer vetting. Data categories included geolocation, health conditions, finances, religion, and children's information. The Brennan Center for Justice documented FBI, IRS, DEA, DHS, and DoD purchasing location data from brokers without warrants. FTC banned X-Mode Social and InMarket from selling precise location data (January 2024). FTC barred Gravy Analytics/Venntel and Mobilewalla from selling location data for users visiting sensitive locations like reproductive health clinics and places of worship (December 2024). CFPB proposed rules to crack down on data broker sales of military and government employee data. Montana became the first state to close the law enforcement data broker loophole (May 2025). Sources: Duke University, Military.com, MIT Technology Review, Lawfare, EFF, Brennan Center for Justice.