E-scooter injury data is uncollectable, blocking safety improvements
transportationtransportation0 views
When an e-scooter rider crashes, the injury is recorded at the ER as 'fall' or 'vehicle accident' with no standardized code distinguishing e-scooter from skateboard, bicycle, or pedestrian fall. So what? Epidemiologists cannot measure the true injury rate, severity distribution, or most common injury mechanisms for e-scooters specifically. So what? Without accurate data, cities cannot identify which intersections, road types, or infrastructure gaps cause the most scooter injuries. So what? Infrastructure spending is allocated based on car crash data and bicycle crash data, leaving scooter-specific hazards (small wheel + pothole, railroad track crossings, wet painted road markings) completely unaddressed. So what? The same preventable injuries repeat year after year at the same locations. This persists because ICD-10 medical codes — the global standard for classifying injuries — only added codes for 'powered scooter' (V00.15) in 2020, and hospital systems take 3-5 years to adopt new codes. Even then, ER staff under time pressure default to generic codes.
Evidence
A 2020 JAMA study found that 28% of e-scooter injuries were miscoded in ER records. ICD-10-CM code V00.15XA for e-scooter injuries was only introduced in October 2020. CDC's WISQARS injury database still cannot filter for e-scooter-specific injuries as of 2024. UCLA Fielding School of Public Health estimated true e-scooter injuries are 2-3x higher than reported due to coding gaps.