73% of IVF patients pay for unproven add-on treatments that clinics recommend without adequate evidence disclosure
healthcarehealthcare0 views
Fertility clinics routinely upsell patients on supplementary procedures and treatments -- known as 'add-ons' -- that lack robust evidence of improving live birth rates, yet 73% of IVF patients reported using at least one add-on during their treatment according to the UK HFEA's 2024 National Patient Survey. These add-ons include DHEA supplements, growth hormones, acupuncture, time-lapse imaging, and PGT-A genetic testing, each adding $1,000-$6,000+ to treatment costs. Why it matters: clinics recommend these add-ons as ways to improve success, so 60% of UK patients who used add-ons did so specifically because their clinic recommended it would increase their chances of having a baby, so patients in an emotionally vulnerable state make financially significant decisions based on incomplete information, so 30% of patients reported not understanding what the add-on treatment was even being used for and only 37% were given an explanation of risks, so patients are spending thousands of dollars on treatments that may provide no benefit while believing they are maximizing their chances. The structural root cause is that fertility clinics have a direct financial incentive to recommend add-ons (which can increase per-cycle revenue by 20-40%), there is no regulatory framework in most countries requiring clinics to disclose the evidence rating of each add-on at the point of sale, and the emotional desperation of patients undergoing IVF makes them highly susceptible to any recommendation that promises even marginal improvement.
Evidence
The HFEA's 2024 National Patient Survey found that 73% of patients used at least one add-on treatment. Among add-on users, 39% used additional medications (DHEA, growth hormones), 27% used acupuncture, and 26% used time-lapse imaging (HFEA, 2024). PGT-A usage nearly doubled from 7% in 2021 to 13% in 2024, despite the HFEA rating it as 'grey' (insufficient evidence) for improving live birth rates for most patients. 60% of patients who used add-ons did so because their clinic recommended it. Only 37% of patients received an explanation of the risks of additional procedures, and 30% did not understand what the treatment was being used for (HFEA National Patient Survey, 2024). HFEA Chair Julia Chain publicly expressed concern over these findings. Class action lawsuits have been filed against genetic testing companies over PGT-A accuracy (Justice Law Collaborative).